Posts Tagged BRUCE WHITAKER
THE FREE FALL OF COUNCIL MEMBER BRUCE WHITAKER’S STATE SENATE CAMPAIGN LED TO HIS LOOSING THE CRA ENDORSEMENT TO NEWCOMER GEORGE SHEN By Barry Levinson
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Bruce Whitaker, Bruce Whitaker.com on April 17, 2018
What is the current result of all my hard work documenting the many failures of Council member Bruce Whitaker’s Fullerton City Council career? It was the California Republican Assembly’s rejection of his attempt to gain the CRA’s endorsement of his candidacy for the State Senate Seat from the 29th District on April 14, 2018. Instead the CRA endorsement went to newcomer George Shen with at least a two thirds majority on the very first ballot.
CRA was not too long ago a hot bed of Bruce Whitaker support…. the oldest and some would say the most conservative Republican organization in the State of California. Not only did he fail to get the endorsement but he snubbed our members by stating he could not attend due to some undisclosed scheduling conflict. He could have easily sent a representative to talk on his behalf. This happens all the time. Yet Whitaker chose not to do this either.
An organization that he used to virtually own based on his past level of support does not even get an appearance from a man seeking our endorsement. Why? Well you do not have to look any further than two members of the Fullerton CRA Chapter, Joe Imbriano and yours truly, the President of the Fullerton chapter. The man who claims he is running to stamp out Sacramento corruption can’t garner enough courage to face two of his local detractors. Cowardice just reached a new level for one Bruce Whitaker. No one will ever make a real difference in Sacramento without a backbone.
Now that his dwindling chances to win this Senate seat has been dealt another severe and most likely fatal blow, we must fight on to make sure that come November 2020 that he is voted off the Fullerton City Council. A politician that was all talk and no action has wasted eight precious years accomplishing virtually nothing. He had such a golden opportunity to make a real difference but in the end he just took up space and sucked up air on the Fullerton City Council dais.
Congratulations to George Shen who won the CRA endorsement for the 29th State Senate District seat. He was the only Republican candidate brave enough and caring enough to speak to us prior to our endorsement vote. Obviously a two thirds majority liked what he had to say to us and appreciated his appearance before our group.
Below I am counting the many ways that Council Member Bruce Whitaker has failed the good people of Fullerton as follows:
1. Bruce Whitaker abstained from voting for a Receive and File motion concerning April 3, 2018 Agenda Item No. 3 entitled “Consideration Of Support For The Department Of Justice Lawsuit Against the State Of California Regarding Sanctuary City Laws”. Whitaker did this about face right after he spoke about his support for the lawsuit and the federal governments authority to deal with immigration. Below is Council member Bruce Whitaker’s key statements as follows:
“Since immigration is predominately and really entirely a federal jurisdiction, it leads me to lean in that direction, to lean in the direction of at least to preserving the federal government’s right to enforce immigration law.”
Whitaker continued: “But as far as being pressed into having to make a call on this, my lean is too support the federal attempts to make California as a border state comply with at least the minimum requirements of immigration law.”
Whitaker goes on to state: “There is more than a little bit of partisanship at play here and there is more than a little bit of political one-upmanship and the tactics of labeling and to shout down people from the other side of the situation. I will not be cowered by those tactics.”
Bruce Whitaker was a total sellout and proved beyond any shadow of a doubt not to be a man of his word. He proved in my opinion that whatever comes out of his mouth should never be taken seriously. He in fact proved himself to be a worthless, spineless, cowardly, self-serving politician who betrayed his own position in the blink of an eye.
This historic betrayal by Republican Bruce Whitaker, a self-proclaimed Constitutional Conservative must be forever remembered by all of you.
How could anyone ever trust him with his or her votes again? I for one will never support him again.
When a politician’s word literally means absolutely nothing, trust has been forever broken between the people they serve and themselves.
Does anyone after all this documentation, still believe that Bruce Whitaker is the right person to serve us in Sacramento from the 29th Senate District?
For this alone Bruce Whitaker’s political career deserves to be ended as soon as possible. That means that you do not vote for Bruce Whitaker for California State Senate for the 29th Senate District or for another term as Fullerton Council member (if he chooses to run). But there is so much more compelling factual information that supports we the voters ending once and for all the political career of one Bruce Whitaker as follows:
2. Bruce Whitaker voted to place Ma’Ayn Johnson, a S.C.A.G. senior planner to our Fullerton Planning Committee. S.C.A.G, the Southern California Association of Governments, has been pushing for high-rise, high-density development and the elimination of the automobile as agents of the United Nations Agenda 21 for decades. S.C.A.G is the largest unelected, taxpayer funded, governmental agency in the country and so-called limited government, Bruce Whitaker voted for her to be on our Fullerton Planning Commission when he himself stated there were 17 well-qualified candidates. This from a politician who claims to be for limited government. So what does total phony politician Bruce Whitaker do but vote for someone who is part of an unelected government body? That Fullertonians is taxation without representation. That goes against the principles of a constitutional republic. His wife incredulously stated sometime after this vote by Whitaker that he is against S.C.A.G. Whitaker to this day has never explained why he voted for a senior planner working for S.C.A.G. What a guy! What a phony politician!
3. Bruce Whitaker refused to respond verbally or in writing to my (Barry Levinson’s) extremely well documented analysis of a 4 to 5 million-dollar finding concerning the Fullerton Golf Course. I am a trained auditor with an MBA and work experience with Ernst and Young, a worldwide CPA firm as well as 12 years as an Internal auditor at the Corporate Headquarters of Northrop Grumman Corporation. I have a total of 35 years of accounting and auditing experience ignored by Council member Bruce Whitaker who appointed me not once but twice to the Parks and Recreation Committee, (which had oversight on the Fullerton Municipal Golf Course). There is absolutely no good reason why Council member Whitaker ignored the Fullerton Golf Course issue. But the reason he removed me is simple. I was apparently getting in the way of the city doing its corrupt, phony deals. I am referring to deals such as the DCCSP, College Town, the Summit House lease extension, and the Revised DCCSP (which would have also removed Polly’s Pies from its current long-time address and basically removed one of the few shopping centers in the eastern part of Fullerton). What a guy! What a phony politician!
4. Bruce Whitaker voted to repeal our Pedophile Residency Restriction Ordinance based on false information that the Fullerton law restricted all sex offenders from living within 2,000 feet of a school, park or licensed day-care center provided by City Attorney James Touchstone. In my public comments I made the point that our law specifically applies to only child sex offenders, not all sex offenders. The only negative court decisions related to laws that restricted all sex-offenders. There was no case law against our much narrower Fullerton law, which impacted only child sex offenders.
Mr. Touchstone in presenting this agenda item to the Fullerton City Council took exception with my comments. He stated as follows:
“With respect, I must disagree with Mr. Levinson and his comments. Specifically, I am looking at the language before you right now of the municipal; code and it states that any sex offender is prohibited from residing within 2,000 feet of any school, park or day care center.” What Touchstone who helped write the law failed to tell the city council members was the definition of sex offender provided by the ordinance at 7.150.020H of the Fullerton Municipal Code is as follows:
“Sex offender means any person required by law to register with government entity as a sex offender for an offense against or involving a child or children, including, but not limited to, the California Sex Offender Registration Act, Penal Code Section 290, et seq.”
Mayor Bruce Whitaker ignored my comments completely and the Fullerton City Council never acknowledged the correction that I brought forth. But more importantly the city council voted at the second hearing for the ordinance to make it law with a unanimous vote again after I proved the City Attorney’s presentation was fatally flawed. Bruce Whitaker and the rest of the city council should be ashamed of themselves to allow a complete and proven falsehood to be used as an excuse to repeal a very important law for the protection of all our children from pedophiles. What kind of a guy allows false information from our City Attorney to be used to support the repeal of a law helping to protect children? The answer is Mayor Bruce Whitaker and the rest of the city council members. What a guy! What a phony and unethical politician!
5. Bruce Whitaker in a November 2014 council meeting stated that there was absolutely no evidence to support the charges brought against me by former Police Chief Dan Hughes. At that meeting Dan Hughes admitted that he could hate that guy (referring to me) and that he took total control of the investigation himself. When was the last time that any police chief took total control of an investigation including contacting people to interview them and then write the police report to the OC District Attorney recommending that they prosecute me? The answer is probably never or at least never in an honest police department. All this time the city, i.e. the police department would not make public the video camera tape where this so-called incident took place. A few weeks after the OCDA refused to charge me with a crime for lack of evidence, the city video was made public and it showed that no crime, no incident took place. Yet after a few others and I asked Bruce Whitaker and the rest of the council to open up an independent investigation on this matter, Whitaker and the rest of the council totally ignored our requests. What kind of a man acknowledges that the police chief’s attempt to railroad me into jail certainly to him appeared to be entirely political payback and yet drops the matter totally? Well that kind of a weak, cowardly man is none other than California 29thSenate District candidate Bruce Whitaker. The fact that he still sits on the Fullerton City council dais is shameful enough but to now want a huge promotion after the shameful way he has handled himself is something only an extremely arrogant, self-center phony politician could do with a straight face. What a guy! What a phony politician!
6. Bruce Whitaker voted for the absolute worst redistricting map, which I call the high-density, high-rise developers and downtown nightclub owners’ map. It is the only map presented to the council that basically disenfranchises the good people who live in and around the downtown area of Fullerton. Rather than being in primarily one district, Popoff’s map divides our downtown residents into five small pieces attached to other neighborhoods throughout Fullerton. This is taxation without adequate representation. Jeremy Popoff, the owner of the Downtown Fullerton Slidebar and a $1,500 contributor to Bruce Whitaker’s past campaigns, wrote this map. Is this a coincidence or not? What a guy! What a phony politician!
7. Bruce Whitaker voted to make Jennifer Fitzgerald our Mayor almost guaranteeing her to be reelected with the help of the title Mayor on the ballot. I bring this up because so very often in speaking with me he stated how much he disagreed with so many of Council member Fitzgerald’s votes. What a guy! What a phony politician!
8. The Agenda item to extend an existing Summit House Restaurant lease deal, which sits on Fullerton City Park land was shameful. The Summit House, not the city already controlled options with the exact same terms including lease revenue to the city to the year 2041. In other words the Summit House was in the drivers seat until the year 2041 or 26 years from the date of this agenda item. But the Summit House wanted more and our totally inept and/or corrupt city council and city manager wanted to give them two additional 10-year lease extensions with the exact same terms all the way to October 2061.
This meant that the city council intentionally bypassed the Park and Recreation Committee for this important agenda issue. I was the only speaker at public comments to point out how the city manager and the city council wrongly bypassed the Park and Recreation Committee. Based on my bringing this failure by the city to the attention of all that night, it resulted in it supposedly going back to our committee for its recommendation before it went to council. Guess what, a little over a month later I learned that the agenda item was withdrawn by the Summit House Restaurant owner.
Question: Would any reasonable businessman leasing out property accept extending a lease with the same current terms for the next 46 years? Why didn’t Bruce Whitaker inform me as his appointee to the Park and Recreation Committee, that this agenda item had wrongly bypassed the Park and Recreation Committee by the city?
Question: Was Bruce Whitaker part of this plan to bypass the P and R Committee? If not, why did he not contact me as his appointee to that committee when he received his council member agenda package several days in advance. The agenda package clearly stated that the lease extension was recommended by the Park and Recreation Department and not the Park and Recreation Committee, which is the normal procedure. What a guy! What a phony politician!
9. Late last year, Bruce Whitaker complained about having to vote on a grant application due to a fast approaching deadline that had not yet been actually filled out by the city. I spoke at the very next city council meeting and informed Whitaker and the rest of the council that all they had to do to solve this problem permanently was to make it mandatory that staff present agenda items not at the last minute but rather at least 2 meetings prior to any deadline. In this way any information absent could be provided by the next meeting assuring that the council and the public had all the information necessary to make a fully informed decision. You would think that every council member especially Bruce Whitaker would be thrilled to finally have a permanent solution to an ongoing problem. But neither Council member Whitaker nor any other council members ever referred to my very easy and quick solution. I have to surmise that Bruce Whitaker’s objection to a grant application without it being filled out was just political gamesmanship to win some points with his constituents. For if he was serious about fixing the ongoing problem he would have pounced on my easy solution immediately. No he ignored my suggestion completely. How sad it is when our politicians are exposed for what they all too often are, which are totally phony self-centered individuals. What a guy! What a phony politician!
10. Just a few short month’s ago as Mayor he led a unanimous vote to appoint David Hendricks our next Fullerton Police Chief. Forty percent of the council was absent that night but Whitaker led the charge to appoint him nevertheless. This shows the arrogance of Whitaker and the council to not wait until all were present to hear all the comments by the public about Hendricks prior to making their final decision. That vote with only 60% of the council present should have never taken place. Yet Whitaker allowed it to happen on his watch as Mayor. I guess we can conclude that this was just another of one of his mental lapses concerning his fiduciary responsibility to his constituents. What a guy! What a phony politician!
11. Whitaker takes no responsibility for all of his political failures. When confronted with the facts that except for legalizing fireworks he has accomplished nothing in his 7 plus years of service, his lame answer is always the same. His answer to these legitimate critiques is that he is only 1 person out of 5 on the dais. What he fails to tell us that Bruce Whitaker has been part of the majority as a Republican the entire time he has represented Fullerton. In fact, he has had either a 4 to 1 majority or a 3 to 2 majority the entire time of his service. Yet now he wants to represent us in the State Senate where he will be one voice out of dozens and his party will be a small minority not the majority he has had for all his time on the Fullerton City Council dais.
12. To those who believed and trusted Bruce Whitaker to represent us honestly based on his many years of his pontificating fiscally conservative values and limited government solutions, he has let us all down. He had such a golden opportunity to make a real difference in our City and instead especially over the past 2 years he decided to place politics and his own ambition in front of the needs of the people he swore to represent.
Concluding Remarks:
With all this factual documentation showing Bruce Whitaker’s actions goes against his so-called constitutional, limited government philosophy, any good conservative would be betraying our cause for transparent, honest conservative leadership by casting a vote for him. The only smart move by the electorate and by the CRA is to not ignore all the facts that I have presented in this article. His turning his back on his most loyal supporters can’t and should not be rewarded with a large promotion. You have let us down big time Council member Bruce Whitaker and hopefully now you will have to pay a political price for your phony political choices and your lack of leadership.
We have now come to learn that the image is so, so different than reality. All of the above examples prove Bruce Whitaker’s betrayal of his so-called constitutional conservative, limited government philosophy. Anyone objective enough to absorb the facts presented here now knows that the reality falls far short from the carefully cultivated image.
Let me state for the record that anyone who decides to vote for Bruce Whitaker with the “lesser of two evils” argument is only fooling themselves. A public servant who in my opinion is deceptive, disingenuous and repeatedly fails to follow his own supposed principles does not deserve your vote.
A Few Final Questions For The 29th State Senate District Voters As Follows:
1. How in good conscience could any parent, grandparent, aunt or uncle vote for a man, Bruce Whitaker who allowed proven false information about a Fullerton ordinance to be justification to repeal a very good law protecting Fullerton children from pedophiles?
2. How in good conscience can any voter support Bruce Whitaker who repeatedly has failed to stand up to Fullerton City corruption over a 7 plus year period while on the Fullerton City Council? Yet now he has the unmitigated gall to base his campaign on pledging to get rid of corruption in Sacramento.
3. How in good conscience could anyone in the 29th California Senate District now cast his or her precious vote for a man who makes a mockery of the very things he has told us he stands for time and time again over his too long and not very distinguished political career?
Fullerton Council Member Bruce Whitaker And Fullerton Council Member Greg Sebourn Both Incredibly Caused Their Own Political Obituaries On April 3, 2018 At The Fullerton City Council. By Barry Levinson
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Bruce Whitaker, Bruce Whitaker.com, Greg Sebourn, Illegal Immigration on April 7, 2018
Here are the pertinent quotes of Fullerton City Council member Bruce Whitaker during the discussion on Agenda Item No. 3 entitled “Consideration Of Support For The Department Of Justice Lawsuit Against The State Of California Regarding Sanctuary City Laws”.
“Since immigration is predominately and really entirely a federal jurisdiction, it leads me to lean in that direction, to lean in the direction of at least to preserving the federal government’s right to enforce immigration law.”
Whitaker continues: “But as far as being pressed into having to make a call on this, my lean is too support the federal attempts to make California as a border state comply with at least the minimum requirements of immigration law.”
Whitaker goes on to state: “There is more than a little bit of partisanship at play here and there is more than a little bit of political one-upmanship and the tactics of labeling and to shout down people from the other side of the situation. I will not be cowered by those tactics.”
With three council members just prior to the vote indicating support in varying degrees for the Agenda Item (Whitaker, Sebourn and Fitzgerald), the vote to approve the Agenda Item incredibly never happened. Instead Council member Jesus Silva made an alternative motion seconded by Mayor Doug Chaffee to Receive and File, which means to file the agenda item away without taking any action on it.
The Final Vote to Receive and File was as follows:
Doug Chaffee, Jesus Silva and Greg Sebourn: YES
Jennifer Fitzgerald: NO
Bruce Whitaker: ABSTAINING
The vote to Receive and File had indeed Bruce Whitaker cowering with an Abstention Vote.
Here are the pertinent statements from Fullerton Council member Greg Sebourn during the discussion on Agenda Item No. 3.
He started by providing the very recent results of a UC Berkley poll that indicated that 74% of all respondents agreed that local authorities should not be able to ignore any request to detain any person who is in this country illegally. The poll found that 82% of Republicans, 73% of Democrats and 71% of Independents opposed California’s Sanctuary State Laws.
He then went on to state that he was in favor of the City of Fullerton writing a letter in support of the repeal of SB54, AB 450 and AB103. These are all laws that foster Sanctuary State policies.
But two minutes after he expressed this support he caved like a demolished building by casting the deciding vote for an alternative motion to Receive and File the Agenda item. This effectively approved doing absolutely nothing to support his just disclosed opposition to SB54, AB450 and AB103. With a backbone like that, I do not know how Sebourn can walk on his own.
Both Bruce Whitaker and Greg Sebourn were total sellouts and proved beyond any shadow of a doubt not to be men of their word. They proved that whatever comes out of their mouths should never be taken seriously. They in fact proved themselves to be worthless, spineless, and totally self-serving politicians who betrayed their own positions in the blink of an eye.
Please remember this historic betrayal by Republican Bruce Whitaker, a self-proclaimed Constitutional Conservative and Republican Greg Sebourn.
How could anyone ever trust them with their votes again? I for one will never support them again.
When a politicians’ word literally means absolutely nothing, trust has been forever broken between the people they serve and themselves.
Does anyone in his or her right mind, still believe that Bruce Whitaker is the right person to serve us in Sacramento from the 29thSenate District?
Does anyone in his or her right mind still believe that Greg Sebourn is the right person to continue to be on the Fullerton City Council?
For this and many more reasons, Bruce Whitaker’s political career and Greg Sebourn’s political career both deserve to be ended as soon as possible. That means that you do not vote for Bruce Whitaker for California State Senate for the 29th Senate District and you do not vote to reelect Greg Sebourn to the Fullerton City Council.
In conclusion, they have both proved that whatever comes out of their mouths can never be counted on by the Fullerton public. They deserve are scorn and our pity but not our precious votes.
Agenda 21, sustainability, SCAG operative, RINO Shawn Nelson wants to drain the swamp while he fills it, backfills it and sits on the drain plug.
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Agenda 21, Bruce Whitaker, Fullerton politics on March 9, 2018
Shawn Nelson is an Agenda 21, sustainability, SCAG operative, establishment politician. With deep connections to regional governments including the biggest and the worst of them all SCAG, and local corrupt polictians he has mentored, I believe he cannot be trusted.
One of the most concerning elements of his behavior on the OC Board of supervisors continues to be his coziness with our corrupt District Attorney’s office and his refusal to act on a Fullerton issue that has been staring him in the face for almost 2 years now.
I had contacted his office on several occasions seeking his assistance with a Fullerton issue. It involved what many and myself to believe to be textbook felony obstruction of justice commited by our former police chief Dan Hughes and others in the Fullerton Police department and a Mr. Bayetieh at the DA’s office that refuses to file charges in spite of overwhelming evidence that his agency is in posession of.
The County Board of Supervisors are called SUPERVISORS BECAUSE THAT IS WHAT THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO BE. The OC Board of Supervisors is the DA’s boss.
Shawn Nelson and his office continued ignoring this issue involving our former city manager and former police chief. It was a major local issue that was the subject of massive media exposure, but like the DA’s watchdogs’ questionable connections, our pathetic Fullerton watchdog Shawn Nelson on the Board of Supervisors, appears to also have questionable connections and that perhaps is why he remains silent protecting what we believe is criminal behavior involving high ranking Fullerton Police department personell. He never responded to any of my attempts to contact his office for assistance.
This issue is so flagrant that the investigator at the DA’s office that was pulled off the case has now had to go to Federal Court to seek redress of his greivances. Santos-Conklin_v_Rackauckas (1)
The Supervisors are supposed to keep their subordinate agencies like the DA in check. Equally troubling was his absolute and total silence on the choice of the watchdog with clearly troubling ties chosen to oversee the Orange County District Attorney’s office as well as his refusal to allow an audit of the Board of Supervisors. These should be of major concern to anyone paying attention. Nelson also has had his share of playing fast and loose with campaign finance rules raising money for a public office he knows he couldn’t run for very recently, funneling tens of thousands of dollars into an account whose future is in question.
Nelson mentors to his lackey underlings who protect corruption and are aligned idealogically with Agenda 21, globalist agendas. Locally he has stacked the city council in Fullerton to vote for all Agenda 21 programs such as adopting international building codes, energy use master plans, legislative support for Agenda 21 regulations, Agenda 21 land use and development master plans, regional government agendas, and various ancillary boards and commissions that are directly involved in Agenda 21 activities such as massive high density development, poisoning our drinking water, spraying us and our trees with dangerous pesticides, restricting water use, forcibly irradiating us with microwave systems and their proliferation, turning our bedroom community into an Agenda 21 compact city, and establishing joint powers authorities at the municipal level which are really all about forced vaccinations. At the core of Agenda 21 is really depopulation which we discussed at legnth here on this site and on you tube. It should come as no surprise that all of the affiliates of this swamp filler and swamp dweller are at odds with what we bring to their attention. It is where we are folks.
So is this some sort of a joke ladies and gentlemen? He wants to help Trump drain the swamp?
Next to Ed Royce, Shawn Nelson has done more to fill the Fullerton swamp than anyone else folks. This is Shawn Nelson’s legacy in Fullerton. He and his wife Sharon filled the Fullerton swamp to the brim with the political pawns that for years expended tremendous effort to maintain the funding and the protecting of the corrupt murderous Fullerton police department,
and protecting the fiscal corruption that has run rampant for decades in a first world city with third world roads. Fullerton is missing hundreds of millions of dollars that should have gone into repairing roads.
The Agenda 21 operatives are well connected in Fullerton. Nelson’s connections to many of them are right out in the open. Take for instance Young Kim, who he is running against in this race ironically,
She was the Agenda 21 Fullerton representative in the State Assembly that gave California forced vaccinations which is clearly an Agenda 21 first rate, top shelf priority.
The mega city model is another Agenda 21 top shelf priority,
As a current SCAG board appointee, he is a bonafide Agenda 21 operative. His past behavior, votes and candidates he supports are all Agenda 21 operatives. Agenda 21 is the most evil and obscene land use, social reingineering experiment in human history. This man must never set foot in Washinton DC unless he is on a tour bus as a tourist.
SCAG is an Unelected, Unconstitutional Regional Government. SCAG (Southern CA Assn. of Governments) is the largest regional government in the US covering 6 counties and 191 cities. SCAG has a $540 Billion plan to remake SoCal in the next 2 decades and operates in Near Darkness.
SCAG is the heartbeat of Agenda 21 and has plans to cram everyone into scientific kill grid compact cities, re wild 95 percent of the United States, get you out of your cars, end fossil fuel consumption, destroy the economy, get you onto public transportation and destroy your our way of life and the freedoms we currently enjoy.
I believe that this man is a dangerous man because he is extremely deceptive, untruthful, knows exactly what he is doing, Yes he is also an attorney. What a shame because God given talent should be used for good and not for evil or selfish gain. Take for example how Shawn Nelson tried to put a homeless shelter right next to a Title I elementary school and right next to an apartment complex in Fullerton that would have netted his good friend Cameron Irons a $100,000 real estate comission. This was resoundingly opposed by Fullerton residents.
Step right up and get your Shawn Nelson endorsement. You know the one Bruce Whitaker and Jennifer Fitzgerald wrap themselves in as they both voted to install a SCAG senior palnner Mayan Johnson to the Fullerton planning commission. Here she is leading the charge to add tens of thousands of apartment units with ten story buildings all over the place on hundreds of acres of Fullerton with the DCCSP.
THIS VIDEO BELOW IS CRUCIAL IN EXPOSING WHAT A TOTAL POLITICAL FRAUD SHAWN NELSON IS.
2 years ago, The Fullerton Republican Women Federated hosted a candidate forum for the City Council Candidates of which it just so happened that I was one of them. He and his wife did everything they could to make sure I was not invited. I managed to attend. Shawn Nelson should have never been the moderator of this forum because he was not impartial by any means and his wife was running the group at the time. A member of the audience had asked a question about the SOUTHER CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENTS otherwise know as SCAG. SCAG is about as relevant to City business as you can get because they dictate planning and social engineering plans for the State. This was not only a fair question, but the most important question of the election.
He refused to allow this question to be asked and listen to his reason why. This is Shawn Nelson, in Agenda 21 mode folks.
Agenda 21 Trojan Horse operative dishonest political fraud Shawn Nelson shows his underbelly as he refers to SCAG as “esoteric”. Yes it is .a secret organization that is ruining our lives and is part of a sinister plan to carry out Agenda 21. Listen to this Orwellian double speak SCAG operative- County Supervisor Shawn Nelson who wants to become your congressman and listen carefully as he talks out of both sides of his mouth.
This SCAG political operative along with his pal Tony Bushala used their influence out in the open to put people in key positions within the city of Fullerton city government to try to pass massive development schemes to add upwards of 100,000 more people to this city. Yes the Agenda 21 DCCSP would have done just that with tens of thousands of apartment units in 10 story buildings on hundreds of acres on just about every major street in town.
If that wasn’t bad enough, we all know that Agenda 21 Trojan Horse RINO phony conservative Shawn Nelson gave us phony conservative RINO, political fraud and liar Jennifer Fitzgerald for our city council and endorsed her for the past 8 years throught 2 election cycles.
Jennifer Fitzgerald REPEATEDLY votes to bankrupt the city with endless raises and giveaways for the police, refuses to take action against criminal behavior by the police and caters to their unions every chance she gets.
Nelson is Jennifer Fitzgerald’s mentor. Jennifer Fitzgerald is Fullerton’s worst nightmare that it hasn’t been able to wake up from for nearly 6 long years. She is a Curt Pringle Fullerton lobbyist for Agenda 21 high density housing and all sorts of eugnenics policies in Fullerton such as microwave system deployment, water fluoridation, Led street light installation and high density housing just to name a few.
She votes for every Agenda 21 massive development and plan that has ever come across her desk.
Jennifer Fitzgerald votes for forced pesticide spraying over all of Fullerton with her position on the vector control board.
Jennifer Fitzgerald makes sure she continues the Agenda 21, deadly, cancer causing water fluoridation with her position on the Metropolitan Water District as an appointee from Fullerton.
On the Fullerton City Council, Jennifer Fitzgerald promotes the consumption of cancer causing and tooth decay causing beverages as the impetus to continue the MWD fluoridation programs.
She continues to vote for dangerous cell tower sitings and 5G deployments right next to homes which guarantee the destruction of wildlife and human health as well as harming our children.
SWAMP FILLER AND SWAMP DWELLER Shawn Nelson backed this woman on the Fullerton City Council for two consecutive terms now and this is the legacy. How would you like to have your bedroom on the second or third floor of one of these Fitzgerald dream projects with the antennae agt eye level?
SWAMP DWELLER Fitzgerald has ignored calls for investigating the missing hundreds of millions of dollars that should have gone into Fullerton’s road repairs. Shame on this horrible SWAMP DWELLING Nelson plant sellout that has turned her back on the residents and sold her soul to telecom and developers.
SWAMP DWELLER Fitzgerald’s swing vote has destroyed Fullerton.
SWAMP FILLER AND SWAMP DWELLER Nelson along with his wife has also backed school board candidates like Janny Meyer
and SWAMP DWELLER Chris Thompson
who voted to destroy our schools and our children BY SPENDING HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS ON horrible child abusing, mentally destroying common core curriculum, common core technology and upgrades, forcing dangerous, highly addictive wireless devices that result in screen time addictions on students while forcing students to be exposed to forced sterilizing microwave exposures, and all while they refuses to protect the children in the district from dangerous pedophiles.
In addition they still refuse to address the serious safety concerns at Parks Junior High like how none of the classrooms have any doors.
SWAMP FILLER AND SWAMP DWELLER Shawn Nelson continues to support political frauds like Bruce Whitaker.
SWAMP DWELLER Nelson plant Agenda 21 sellout phony Bruce Whitaker is one of the biggest political frauds in Fullerton history. Like SWAMP DWELLER Jennifer Fitzgerald, SWAMP DWELLER Bruce Whitaker is an Agenda 21 operative who voted to put the SCAG senior planner on our planning commission so they could add tens of thousands of high density housing units in Fullerton with the DCCSP. He and his appointee to the planning commission refuse to speak a work against this Agenda 21 development scheme to this day. Bruce Whitaker is a political fraud.
Bruce continues to ignore the aerosol spraying operations in the skies over Fullerton, ignores the warnings and pleas to end the Agenda 21 geo engineered drought while continues to vote for water restrictions.
SWAMP FILLER AND SWAMP DWELLER SHAWN NELSON has continued to support Bruce Whitaker through two election cycles.
SWAMP FILLER AND SWAMP DWELLER SHAWN NELSON’s lackey SWAMP DWELLER Bruce Whitaker continues to IGNORE AND REFUSES to call for an audit of the city’s finances inspite of repeated calls for an investigation and an audit to fine the missing hundreds of millions of dollars that should have gone into Fullerton road repair.
SWAMP FILLER AND SWAMP DWELLER Shawn Nelson and Tony Bushala have long since worked together to shape Fullerton’s political landscape to suit their own corrupt agendas for years.
SWAMP FILLER AND SWAMP DWELLER SHAWN NELSON ‘s plants Whitaker and Fitzgerald refused to deal with this local taxpayer ripoff issue as well for almost a year.
Nelson has given us a living nightmare politically in Fullerton and he is not worthy of being called a conservative, muchless capabale of draining anything, forget a Washington swamp. Shawn Nelson is a swamp dweller ladies and gentlemen. Don’t let the ladies fool you either folks.
FOLKS IF YOU BELIEVE SHAWN NELSON IS GOING TO DRAIN ANYTHING IN WASHINGTON, THEN I HAVE BEACHFRONT PROPERTY IN THE MOJAVE DESERT WITH A MANGROVE FOREST I CAN SELL YOU.
SWAMP FILLERS AND SWAMP DWELLERS LIKE SHAWN NELSON HAVE NO BUSINESS DOING THE PEOPLE’S BUSINESS IN WASHINGTON FOLKS. IT IS TIME TO WAKE UP AND LOOK PAST HIS LIES AND LOOK AT WHAT THIS MAN HAS DONE TO FULLERTON.
PLEASE DO NOT ALLOW THIS DECEPTIVE, USELESS ESTABLISHMENT POLITICIAN EXPAND HIS INFLUENCE TO THE FEDERAL LEVEL. IF WHAT HE HAS DONE TO FULLERTONIANS IN FULLERTON IS ANY INDICATION WHAT HE WILL DO TO US IN WASHINGTON DC, CONSIDER YOURSELVES WARNED.
How Did The City Of Fullerton Get This Bad? Hint: It Took A Concerted Effort To Put Fullertonians Last By Our Failed, Phony And Gutless Politicians! The Current Culprits : Jennifer Fitzgerald, Bruce Whitaker (I’ve accomplished nothing in almost eight years….time to get a big promotion.), Doug Chaffee (Rumor has it that he wants his wife to succeed him. I guess he thinks their royalty.), Jesus Silva and Greg Sebourn.
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Who's who in Fullerton politics on February 9, 2018
HAS STATE SENATE CANDIDATE BRUCE WHITAKER FULLERTON SPENT MONEY FROM HIS PRECIOUS LITTLE WAR CHEST ON CLEANING UP HIS REPUTATION ON THE INTERNET? by Barry Levinson
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Bruce Whitaker, Bruce Whitaker.com on January 15, 2018
It certainly appears that way to me Fullertonians. There have been many, many negative articles on the internet spelling out the many failures of one Bruce Whitaker Fullerton City Council member.
https://thefullertoninformer.com/category/bruce-whitaker/
Yet one day a few weeks ago I noticed that when I put his name in the Google or Yahoo browser almost no negative articles appeared about him. How strange, how curious….or is it? Did our so-called libertarian candidate spend money to alter what articles appears on the internet when anyone looks up his name?
Like I said it certainly appears to be the case. Is this just another example of the phoniness of one Bruce Whitaker?
Search Results are being suppressed by Mr fake Statesmen online reputation defender software hiding the truth that Bruce Whitaker doesn’t want the voters to see.
Bruce Whitaker ignores what is going on at the Fullerton … – YouTube
Mike Blackstone, Barry Levinson and Joe Imbriano speak at the 11-21-17 FullertonCity council meeting as Air …
Bruce Whitaker Fullerton City Council joining the ranks of … – YouTube
Pedophile protectors on the Fullerton City Council Bruce Whitaker, Jesus Silva, Greg Sebourn, Doug Chaffee …
Bruce Whitaker addresses the attempted framing of Barry … – YouTube
Bruce Whitaker addresses the attempted framing of Barry Levinson Fullerton City Council 11-4-14 and watch …
Bruce Whitaker ignoring two of his staunchest supporters … – YouTube
Bruce Whitaker choosing to ignore two of his staunchest supporters who had questions concerning David …
Bruce Whitaker ignores Joe Imbriano as he questions why Fullerton has totally abandoned almost all street …
By his own actions, he has become both irrelevant and a joke to most Fullertonians. I suspect the rest of the 29th Senate District will soon come to the exact same conclusion.
PS: Hint: If you type in “Corrupt Bruce Whitaker Fullerton”, you will see some of the articles written that documents very well a host of Bruce Whitaker’s failings and shortcomings.
Tony Bushala’s Josh Newman just may have a chance to deliver that payday after all
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Agenda 21, Josh Newman, Tony Bushala, Who's who in Fullerton politics on January 15, 2018
Remember these signs? The group Fullerton Taxpayers for Reform was responsible for these campaign signs during the June 2016 primary election against State Senate candidate Sukhee Kang.
The signs reading “No Kang – Irvine Carpetbagger” were paid for by the Fullerton committee called Fullerton Taxpayers for Reform whose principal officers are none other than Tony Bushala and Jack Dean.
Was this “No Kang Irvine Carpetbagger” campaign designed to pave the way for none other than Josh Newman to write his ticket for the November ballot? Well there WERE NO OTHER DEMOCRATIC CANDIDATES IN THE RACE for the June Primary and I certainly didn’t see Dean and Bushala’s group supporting Ling Ling Chang the Republican challenger.
The intentions of the Fullerton Taxpayers for Reform were to knock Kang out of the primary election, so that Newman, would end up on the November ballot and win. You see the Agran plant, Khang couldn’t be bothered with Bushala because he has already been bought and paid for by a camp at odds with Bushala. So many strings controlling things so hard to keep track. So what could have been the motivations of Tony Bushala and Jack Dean to inject their group and exert its influence into a Senate primary election? Was it to ensure Josh Newman’s place in Sacramento? To have a “friend obligated to return a favor in high places? Everyone knew that the anti Trump sentiment among the Latinos was going to fair well for the Democrats in this part of Orange County. Any politically savy individual would know that massive Latino voting block coupled with the illegals that have been registered to vote all showed up in droves. That is how we ended up with Jesus Silva on the City Council and Sharon Quirk Silva in the Assembly both edging out Republicans.It just had to be a homegrown dem for Bushala to play ball with.
Does Bushala’s meddling in this Senate race have anything to do with development? Of course it did. Is Jack Dean just along for the ride unaware of the Bushala high rise development agenda? It is doubtful. Jack is a smart man. We do know that an end run around local control over high density housing approvals has been the subject of several unsuceesful bills out of Sacramento just this year. It would certainly bode well for Bushala to bypass his plants on the council which have been hogtied by the relentless pressure of local activists.
Then we have the Shawn Nelson school of political science at work-focus on a narrow item like a tax and make it all about that. That is what Tony’s tool Sebourn did during the recall.
Isn’t it ironic how Bushala’s blog, The Friends for Fullerton’s Future is currently hosting articles that are promoting the recall of Josh Newman and they make it all about a gas tax? What did you expect a Democrat to do, vote down a tax increase? You think Newman will vote down Agenda 21, socialism that involves state mandated affordable housing construction? Heck no.
Well folks, Bushala was behind Newman all along and SB 827 just rolled off the printer in Sacramento a few days ago.
Bushala funded Bruce Whitaker for years and it just so happens that he is challenging Josh Newman who Bushala helped get elected in the recall election if it suceeds. Whitaker is full of crap if he acts like he wont support this bill because if Bruce had it his way, there would be no zoning at all. Whitaker is running a political con job while his most ardent supporter is Bushala is playing both sides of the aisle once more to ensure his influence finds its way to the Capital where SB 827 and other bills like it will find their way to the Senate floor for a full vote so they can make his family alot of money and ruin Fullerton for good with huge ten or twenty story apartment buildings all over the place.
This is a nightmare for Fullerton as this could add hundreds of thousands more people to Fullerton if a bill like this passes. Will this be a Bushala dream come true? Of course. For years he has from behind the scenes, attempted unsuceesfully to maneuver his political pawns to get huge develeopments through at the local level. His family owns a very large amount of properties around the train station. Tony Bushala is the father of transit oriented high density housing in Fullerton. SB 827 strips all local control away from cities and allows huge transit rich high density housing to be built within 1/2 to 1/4 mile of any transit center with virtually no height limits or parking requirements. This is nothing more than the State version of the DCCSP and the end of our quality of life in Fullerton as we know it.
Political operatives like Bushala can turn on someone on a dime when the wind starts blowing the wrong way. We sure have seen plenty of that in Fullerton.
No matter what the outcome of this recall and the subsequent elections, you have my word that we will continue to objectively work towards draining the swamp at City Hall, exposing and ridding Fullerton of its political operatives and continue fighting this Agenda 21 legislation designed to create the scientific kill grids in the compact cities as they get everyone into these high rise arrangements so they can be force vaccinated, microwaved, have their water dosed, drugged, doped up, medicated, fed the GMO’s, mind controlled with the TV screens everywhere and finally finished off to reduce the population. These creeps that want to turn Fullerton into downtown LA or New York City have another thing coming. On this my friends, you have my word.
PINEWOOD STAIRS FALLING APART AND YET STATE SENATOR CANDIDATE BRUCE WHITAKER REMAINS TOTALLY SILENT. by Barry Levinson
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Bruce Whitaker, Bruce Whitaker.com, Hidden in plain view, Highway Robbery, Hilcrest Stairs, Hillcrest stairs, Jesus Silva, Tony Bushala, Who's who in Fullerton politics on January 14, 2018
It has been approximately 8 to 9 months since the City’s Christening of the Pinewood Stairs connecting Hillcrest Park and Lion’s Field. The FFFF website has posted new pictures rendering the condition of those stairs. They are simply falling apart with the problems increasing at a very rapid rate.
Yet where is State Senate Candidate Bruce Whitaker on this issue? The answer is that Bruce Whitaker has been totally silent since the beginning. It is very troubling that someone whose only theme for running for State Senate is to fight Sacramento Corruption is once again totally silent on this City of Fullerton corruption and there is no doubt that is what Pinewood Stairs represents.
Sebourn mentioned his concern in response to citizen complaints and then failed to follow-up at all. Nice phony PR work Sebourn.
Fitzgerald’s response was to totally praise the stairs as a great triumph of city engineering and development.
Who is one of her main supporters and mentors but none other than Shawn Nelson who is now running to replace Congressman Ed Royce. You remember Nelson, the guy who tried to put in a homeless shelter across the street from an elementary school that has many special needs children in attendance and tried to hand over a 100K commission to one of his supporters denying others the right to bid for that commission. The same supervisor who was against setting up an independent commission to look into OC Supervisor corruption. Here is Nelson hiding SCAG from the public at a candidate forum, yes the one who lobbied his head off to make sure Jennifer Fitzgerald got elected twice and he wants to be your Congressman?
Is this the best the Republican Party can provide as candidates, Bruce Whitaker for State Senate and Shawn Nelson for U.S. Congress? How pathetic? And the State Republican party wonders why Republicans have become pretty much meaningless throughout the entire state. A state that gave us Governor and then President Ronald Reagan. Should those true conservatives that care about our constitution and limited government providing freedom for its citizens, start a new Conservative Party in California? If the State Republican Party does not shape up and shape up really fast, the answer is probably yes!
As for the stairs, well you know you can’t put wood in concrete like that. It swells every time it gets wet. It should have had metal anchors with straps and bolts. So if the City doesn’t sue the contractor for construction defects, no one gets fired, no one goes to jail for this total ripoff, and someone gets hurt when this thing ends up red tagged after the next big rainstorm, well you know it will be you picking up the tab once again.
I report, you decide.
TERRIFIC SUMMATION OF HOW DESPICABLY THE FULLERTON CITY COUNCIL (BRUCE WHITAKER, JENNIFER FITZGERALD, GREG SUBOURN, JESUS SILVA, DOUG CHAFFEE AND THE THE CITY ATTORNEY (DICK JONES AND A PARTNER JAMES TOUCHSTONE) REPEALED OUR CHILD SEX RESIDENCY RESTRICTION ORDINANCE (3149) BACK IN FEBRUARY 2017. By Barry Levinson
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Are they turning their backs on the children?, Pedophile protectors on the Fullerton City Council on December 23, 2017
Is 100 million dollars missing from Fullerton City Hall? Joe Imbriano asks the hard questions.
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Fullerton politics, FULLERTON PRAVDA, Highway Robbery, Who's who in Fullerton politics on December 7, 2017
Joe Imbriano questions why Fullerton has totally abandoned almost all street repair for decades. All other surrounding cities have the same issues with out of control pensions, payroll, and benefits costs and yet these surrounding cities have managed to repave all of their streets year after year and keep their streets in workable order.
Meanwhile, Fullerton, with its huge property tax and sales tax base has its streets, water mains, and sewer pipes, almost all 200 miles of them crumbling in ruin while these stool pigeons on the council look the other way and push for massive highrise development and dirty favors for their crony pals. No longer will this and other issues be ignored. We want answers and we aim to get them. Use your head folks, do the math and open your eyes. Something is seriously wrong in Fullerton that in my opinion, is going to make the Bell scandal look like a lemonade stand heist.
You decide for yourself.
PEDOPHILES VS. KIDS AND THE FULLERTON CITY COUNCIL VOTED FOR THE PEDOPHILES
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Pedophile protectors on the Fullerton City Council on October 4, 2017
WHY DID THE CITY OF FULLERTON GOVERNMENT JUSTIFY THE REPEAL OF A LAW TO PROTECT KIDS FROM PEDOPHILES BASED ON KNOWN FALSE INFORMATION? PEDOPHILES VS. KIDS AND THE FULLERTON CITY COUNCIL VOTED FOR THE PEDOPHILES AND AGAINST OUR KIDS SAFETY! THANKS FOR NOTHING MAYOR BRUCE WHITAKER, COUNCIL MEMBERS JENNIFER FITZGERALD, GREG SEBOURN, DOUG CHAFFEE AND JESUS SILVA!
There are two kinds of pedophiles. The first kind are those who recognize the evil desire they have toward children and try to fight the urges to re-committ these heinous crimes. These pedophiles try to stay away from places, which prove to be the greatest temptation; i.e. schools, parks, playgrounds, etc. The second kind of pedophile feels absolutely no remorse and is on the hunt for innocent children 24/7. Which kind of pedophile do you think sues governments to repeal laws that restrict them from living near a school, park or day-care center? Which city with a proven false legal justification decided anyway to repeal our law without any legal fight….our Fullerton City Council, all of them…MAYOR BRUCE WHITAKER, COUNCI MEMBERS JENNIFER FITZGERALD, GREG SUBORN, DOUG CHAFFEE AND HUSBAND TO STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER SHARON QUIRK-SILVA, HESUS SILVA! THEY KNEW BECAUSE MYSELF AND OTHERS TOLD THE CITY COUNCIL THAT THER HAS BEEN NO CALIFORNIA COURT DECISION AT ANY LEVEL that has dealt with the residence restriction of ONLY CHILD SEX OFFENDERS in our State of California, arguably the most far-left state in the nation. I hope and pray that one day soon, the good people of Fullerton will hold each and everyone of those arrogant, deceitful and contemptible council members accountable for their despicable votes to leave our children in Fullerton more vulnerable to pedophiles.
IF YOU WANT TO BE TAKEN SERIOUSLY AND SLEEP LIKE A BABY AT NIGHT YOU MUST PUT THE TRUTH FIRST.
Posted by Joe Imbriano in Bruce Whitaker, JOSHUA FERGUSON on August 3, 2017
BY BARRY LEVINSON
THE TRUTH
IT IS WHAT I TRULY BELIEVE IN. WELL IN THE CASE OF STATE SENATOR CANDIDATE JOSHUA FERGUSON’S RESPONSE UNDER THE FFFF ARTICLE “THE WHITAKER RECORD” HE TOLD THE TRUTH. I BELIEVE ALL PEOPLE SHOULD GET CREDIT FOR THEIR TRUTHFUL STATEMENTS MADE ON THE RECORD. HERE ARE HIS COMMENTS, WHICH I TOTALLY AGREE WITH.
The Whitaker Record
August 3, 2017 Joe Sipowicz Comments(25)
Joshua Ferguson (comment)
“Okay, I’ll bite.
You’re mad because you can’t get a good wine so what do you do?
Apparently you sit on the sidelines and complain that you can’t get good wine as it gets worse and worse each year. I’d rather try and make wine. That’s EXACTLY why Napa is world renowned for wine. Delusional people set out to make a change.
You can consider me delusional all you want but I’d rather be delusional than a defeatist.
I would have never thrown my name in and would have eagerly supported Whitaker if I thought he’d fight. But he won’t and he hasn’t.
We have serious allegations of police misconduct & obstruction of justice in the Felz case alone. Whitaker is Mayor. What has he done to get to the bottom of it?
Be precise about the actions in this case. I’ll award bonus points for source citations.
As a reminder the former police chief allegedly obstructed justice on his way out of the door. The DA allegedly ignored it owing to political favors.
Do we need to put a ribbon on the tee before the bat is swung? We can’t swing it for the council. The whole council is complicit in this corruption but the Mayor has the power to put things on the Agenda. He doesn’t. I see a new higher paid chief from a problematic department. That’s it. Where’s the oversight? Reform? Investigation? Anything?
Oh I know. Despite the council being 3-2 (R) he doesn’t think he can accomplish anything so its better to do nothing.
Put it on record. Put reform and an investigation on the agenda and make the opposition take a pro-cover-up position. Make them make the pro-corruption vote. Do something. Be the voice you ran to be and fight for us and if you won’t don’t be surprised if allies get fed up and try to use their own voices you seem intent on ignoring.
Newman is being recalled because he lied to voters and opted to rob us blind. I’m not about to vote for somebody else who will sit silently owing to a minority position while we still get robbed.
I’ve had enough of (R)s who say they’d do the right thing if only they had power. Fight for the right thing or you’ll never get the chance.”
That concludes Mr. Ferguson’s remarks. As I stated in my title of this article, I give people credit for telling the truth in a public forum. Ferguson has been supportive of Mayor Bruce Whitaker and an ally in the past. The fact that he was willing to look at Whitaker’s public performance to judge whether he is worthy of Ferguson’s support is admirable. Two fellow conservatives Sean Paden and David Curlee, still in my opinion see Mayor Whitaker thru rose color glasses.
Paden goes out of his way to support him no matter what the facts state. Blind allegiance in politics is extremely dangerous.
The big question is whether I would vote for Ferguson. There are a few issues that I would need to hear more from him on. I have seen him in a few instances, in my humble opinion, put saving taxpayer dollars ahead of the overall benefit to the community. I am a fiscal conservative and hate to see any taxpayer monies wasted but government has a role and sometimes monies need to be in fact spent for the benefit of the overall community.
In conclusion, my answer as of August 3, 2017 is that I would give his candidacy serious consideration. It is early and we may not know the names of all candidates who will throw their hats into the ring.
But the bottom line, I appreciate very much Ferguson’s above comments concerning Bruce Whitaker and see it as his taking an independent second look at a former ally. It takes a certain amount of courage to distance yourself from someone you used to support wholeheartedly.
Finally, as Ferguson said above…”Okay, I’ll bite.” ` I am glad he did.
BARRY LEVINSON
Recent Comments